AI Tools · Trade Analyzer

Accept or reject.
Here’s the answer.

Stop checking four tabs before every trade decision. Verdict evaluates both sides of any deal against your specific roster — algorithmic scoring, AI player context, and counter-offer suggestions included.

Start Free — Connect Your League

Trade Verdicts are a Pro feature · Free includes the full player database and Trade Finder

The problem

Trade value charts tell you what players are worth. Not whether the trade is right for your team.

Here’s a familiar sequence: someone proposes a trade, you open a trade value chart in one tab, a second one in another, skim a Reddit thread, half-remember a podcast take from two weeks ago, and 40 minutes later you’re still not sure. Trade value charts give you aggregate market consensus. You’re the one who has to translate that into whether it fits your roster, your competitive window, and your positional gaps.

Verdict does. The Trade Analyzer scores every deal against your actual roster situation — dynasty value, win-now impact, positional balance, competitive window — and delivers a clear recommendation. Not data to interpret. A verdict. Accept, reject, or here’s the counter-offer.

How it works

From trade proposal to verdict in three steps.

Open the trade

Your Sleeper trade inbox syncs automatically. Incoming proposals are already scored when you open the app. Or build any hypothetical — players, picks, FAAB — using the manual trade builder.

Verdict scores both sides

The algorithm calculates dynasty value, win-now delta, and value balance for every piece. AI analysis adds player-level context — trajectory, fit, competitive window impact — so you see the math and the reasoning.

Accept, reject, or counter

You get a clear verdict on whether to make the trade, backed by the reasoning: dynasty value, win-now impact, and positional fit. If the deal isn’t quite right, Verdict generates three counter-offer options — conservative, moderate, or aggressive — so you negotiate from data, not gut feeling.

Features

Everything you need to decide on a trade.

Algorithmic Scoring

Every trade gets a dynasty delta, win-now delta, and total value balance. Actual math applied to your specific roster — so you see exactly what you gain and what you give up.

Clear Verdicts, Not Charts

A direct recommendation with the reasoning behind it. You know exactly where the deal stands — and why. No more “it depends” from a podcast host who hasn’t seen your roster.

Counter-Offer Generator

If the deal isn’t right, don’t walk away empty-handed. Verdict generates three counter-offer options — conservative, moderate, and aggressive — each with a clear pitch you can use directly.

Sleeper Inbox Sync

Pending trade proposals from Sleeper appear in your Verdict inbox automatically. No copying rosters, no manual setup. Open the app and your decisions are already waiting.

AI Player Breakdowns

Each player in the trade gets an individual assessment — upside, risk, positional fit, and how their trajectory aligns with your competitive window. You understand the trade, not just the score.

IDP First-Class

Linebackers, defensive linemen, and defensive backs are scored the same way offensive players are. If your league has IDP, Verdict accounts for it. No workarounds. No “IDP coming soon.”

The difference

Trade calculators give you numbers. Verdict gives you a decision.

Trade value charts compare two aggregate market values and hand you the rest to figure out. That’s useful for a gut check. It’s not a decision.

Verdict knows your roster. It knows whether you’re 8-2 and pushing for a championship run or 3-7 and selling veterans. It knows you have three quarterbacks and zero tight ends. When you get a trade proposal, the question isn’t just “who’s worth more.” It’s “does this make my team better?” Those are different questions. Verdict answers the right one.

FAQ

Questions about Trade Analyzer

How is this different from a trade value calculator?

Trade value calculators show aggregate market consensus — what the community thinks a player is worth on average. Verdict evaluates the specific deal against your specific roster. It factors in your dynasty vs. win-now balance, your positional needs, and where you are in your competitive window. Same inputs, completely different question being answered.

Does it work for incoming proposals or only trades I build myself?

Both. Your Sleeper trade inbox syncs automatically — incoming proposals are already in your Verdict inbox when you open the app. You can also build any hypothetical trade manually using the trade builder: players, picks, and FAAB from any team in your league.

What does the verdict actually tell me?

Whether to make the trade, and why. Close calls get a directional recommendation instead of a flat yes/no. Every verdict comes with a written explanation — dynasty value, win-now impact, and positional fit — not just an answer.

Does Verdict support IDP leagues?

Yes. Linebackers, defensive linemen, and defensive backs are scored with the same methodology as offensive players. If your Sleeper league includes IDP, Verdict automatically includes those positions in trade analysis and counter-offer suggestions. No workarounds needed.

What does the counter-offer generator actually give me?

Three fully-formed counter-offer suggestions — conservative (minimal adjustment to make the deal fairer), moderate (a balanced restructure), and aggressive (press your advantage). Each one includes the specific pieces to send and receive plus a ready-to-send pitch you can drop directly into Sleeper.

The next trade proposal deserves a real answer.

Connect your Sleeper league in 30 seconds. Your trade inbox is already waiting.