Pheldarius Payne, DL Colts | Dynasty Ranking & Value

Pheldarius Payne carries a 38.0 dynasty score, ranking 502 at DL. With a 100th percentile age trajectory, Payne’s production is expected to continue increasing as he enters his third year in the league.

Payne’s 2025 season stats indicate a decline in production, with a 0th percentile production grade. His Verdict efficiency grade at the 50th percentile suggests he is still efficient, but his usage is decreasing. Payne’s contract situation, with one year remaining and a $840,000 APY, provides limited role security.

No injury entries in 2025. Given his Verdict durability grade at the 75th percentile and his age, Payne’s injury risk is moderate.

With a Verdict usage grade at the 50th percentile, his role is not secure, and he faces competition from other defensive linemen.

Sean Duggan coordinates a 4-3 defense with a 21.0% blitz rate. This scheme helps Payne’s production, as he is well-suited for a 4-3 defense with his size and athleticism.

Declining. As Payne’s production grades fall to the 0th percentile, his age and contract situation will likely limit his growth.

Ceiling: DL2-DL3. For Payne to reach this ceiling, he must improve his production and efficiency grades, and his role must become more secure. Floor: DL5. If Payne’s production continues to decline, and his role is not secure, he will likely fall to the DL5 tier.