Michael Badgley, K Colts | Dynasty Ranking & Value

Michael Badgley carries a 49.0 dynasty score, ranking 35 at K. He had 57 fantasy points in 9 games in 2025 and is entering a contract year.

Badgley had 57 fantasy points in 9 games in 2025. His Verdict efficiency grade is at the 25th percentile, indicating room for improvement. With his current level of performance, he will be a key factor in the Colts’ offense in 2026. His ability to maintain consistency will be a significant factor in reaching his full potential. Entering a contract year, Badgley will have the opportunity to secure a long-term deal, which could significantly impact his value. As a free agent in 2026, his future with the team is uncertain, and he may face competition for the kicker role.

No injury entries in 2025.

Badgley played in 9 games in 2025. The limited playing time may have hindered his ability to gain momentum and consistency throughout the season. He may face competition for the kicker role in 2026.

The Colts’ run-heavy offense may limit Badgley’s ceiling, potentially affecting his ability to score consistently.

Stable: Badgley has maintained stable production over his career, with a steady Verdict production grade at the 35th percentile.

Ceiling: K2-K3. Badgley must maintain his current production and secure the kicker role to reach his ceiling. Floor: K5-K6. Badgley’s trade value is 245, indicating a moderate floor risk.