Summary
Matthew Butler carries a 43.0 dynasty score, ranking 421 at DL. His 18th percentile production grade from Verdict Scores indicates a declining trajectory heading into 2026 at age 26.
Projection Rationale
Butler’s 7 solo tackles and 0 sacks in 12 games indicate a decreasing role in the Dolphins’ defense. His 41st percentile durability grade and 68th percentile contract grade from Verdict Scores suggest he will remain with the team through 2027. The Shanahan-tree offense under Bobby Slowik will likely limit Butler’s pass-rushing opportunities.
Injury Risk
No injury entries in 2025. Butler’s age and 100th percentile age trajectory grade from Verdict Scores indicate a low risk of injury.
Opportunity Notes
Butler’s snap share percentage trended down from 32.6% in 2025. The Dolphins’ 4-3 defense under Sean Duggan may limit his opportunities.
Scheme Fit Analysis
Sean Duggan coordinates a 4-3 defense with a 21.0% blitz rate. The Shanahan-tree offense under Bobby Slowik may limit Butler’s pass-rushing opportunities.
Trend Assessment
Declining. Butler’s production grade from Verdict Scores has declined to the 18th percentile, indicating a downward trend in his performance.
Ceiling / Floor
Butler’s ceiling is DL4-DL5, requiring a significant increase in his pass-rushing production. His floor is DL6-DL7, given his declining production and limited role.
Comparable Player
Darnell Dockett, 2007-2011.