Indianapolis Colts

Arden Key, DL Colts | Dynasty Ranking

Age
30
·
Sleeper ID
5067
Verdict scores
Trade Value 2,876
Win-Now 2.1/10
Consistency 0
Positional Rank 107
Trade Value Tier B
Trend → Stable
Scouting report

Summary

Arden Key carries a 79.0 dynasty score, ranking 107 at DL. Key’s production decreased in 2025 with 4 sacks in 12 games, and he’s expected to become a free agent after the 2026 season.

Projection Rationale

In 2025, Key accumulated 9 solo tackles, 6 tackles for loss, and 4 sacks in 12 games, indicating a moderate production trajectory. His efficiency grade is at the 78th percentile, while his usage grade is at the 58th percentile, indicating possible decreased playing time. Key’s contract situation is uncertain after the 2026 season, which may impact his role security.

Injury Risk

Key suffered injuries in 2025, including a Week 18 absence due to a non-participation in practice and several questionable or out designations. His durability grade is at the 88th percentile, indicating reduced playing time.

Opportunity Notes

Key’s snap share percentage trended up in 2025, from 61.0% in Week 14 to 81.0% in Week 15. There is competition for the role, as Key is expected to become a free agent after the 2026 season.

Scheme Fit Analysis

Lou Anarumo coordinates a 4-3 defense with a 27.7% blitz rate. Key’s production was limited in a zone-heavy 4-3 scheme, which may impact his ceiling.

Trend Assessment

Declining. Key’s production decreased in 2025 with 4 sacks in 12 games, and his Verdict grade is at the 88th percentile, indicating reduced playing time.

Ceiling / Floor

Key’s ceiling is DL2-DL3, requiring a significant increase in playing time and production. His floor is DL5, considering his reduced playing time and impending free agency.

Comparable Player

Lee Roy Selmon, 1976-82.