Josh Butler, DB Dallas Cowboys | Dynasty Ranking & Value

Josh Butler carries a 69.0 dynasty score, ranking 222 at DB. Butler’s 2025 season production indicates a steady floor, but his 62nd percentile production grade suggests room for growth at age 29 with one year remaining on his contract.

Butler’s 3 solo tackles in 17 games indicate a steady floor, but his 62nd percentile production grade suggests he may see increased opportunities for tackles and turnovers in 2026. The Cowboys’ 4-3 defense with a 28.2% blitz rate under Matt Eberflus could also benefit Butler’s pass coverage and blitzing responsibilities. With one year remaining on his contract, Butler’s role and production are somewhat secure.

Butler had limited participation in practice for Week 17, but practiced fully in Week 18. His Verdict durability grade percentile is at the 18th percentile, indicating a moderate injury risk profile at age 29.

Butler’s snap share percentage remained stable at 35.0% in 2025. However, the Cowboys’ 4-3 defense under Matt Eberflus could provide opportunities for improvement in pass coverage and blitzing responsibilities.

Sean Duggan coordinates a 4-3 defense with a 28.2% blitz rate. The zone-heavy coverage under Duggan could limit Butler’s ceiling in man coverage, but his role in the blitz package may increase.

Stable. Butler’s snap share percentage remained steady at 35.0% in 2025, indicating a consistent role in the Cowboys’ defense.

Butler’s ceiling is DB2-DB3, requiring increased opportunities for tackles and turnovers in 2026. His floor is DB4-DB5, with a trade value of 2,277, indicating a lower-tier asset if his role and production decline.