Cleveland Browns

DeCarlos Nicholson, DB CLE | Dynasty Ranking & Value

Age
24
·
Sleeper ID
13753
Verdict scores
Trade Value 105
Win-Now 0.5/10
Consistency 0
Positional Rank 1069
Trade Value Tier D
Trend → Stable
Scouting report

Summary

DeCarlos Nicholson carries a 5.0 dynasty score, ranking 1069 at DB. As a 24-year-old with one year of experience, Nicholson’s career trajectory is just beginning to unfold.

Projection Rationale

His 35th percentile Verdict grade durability may impact his long-term outlook. This could potentially limit his playing time and overall effectiveness. Nicholson has one year remaining on his contract with a $1.3 million annual salary. His contract situation will be a key factor in determining his future prospects.

Injury Risk

No injury entries in 2025. Nicholson’s Verdict durability grade is at the 35th percentile, placing him at a moderate risk due to his age and experience level, which may lead to increased susceptibility to injuries.

Opportunity Notes

His role appears secure, but competition from other defensive backs may arise in the future, potentially altering his playing time and responsibilities.

Scheme Fit Analysis

Mike Rutenberg coordinates a 4-3 defense with a 33.9% blitz rate. Nicholson benefits from the defense’s heavy zone coverage, which should allow him to make more plays on the ball and contribute to the team’s overall defensive performance.

Ceiling / Floor

Nicholson’s ceiling is DB2-DB3, requiring consistent production and reduced injury risk. His floor is DB5, reflecting his trade value of 105 and moderate risk profile, which may impact his long-term value.

Comparable Player

Mike Harden, 1985-1992