Why Verdict

One tool instead of five. And it covers defense.

Verdict replaces the fragmented dynasty workflow — trade calculator, value chart, scouting site, group chat poll, gut feeling — with one Sleeper-native platform that covers offense and IDP.

The problem

The five-tab problem

Here’s how most dynasty managers make a single decision. Open a trade calculator to check values. Open a different site for scouting. Pull up a ranking list. Browse a forum thread for a second opinion. Fire up ChatGPT to ask if the deal makes sense. Forty minutes later, you either send the trade or close all the tabs and forget about it.

And that’s just offense. On defense? You’re guessing. The trade calculator doesn’t cover your linebacker. The scouting site has nothing on your safety. The ranking list stopped updating in October. Half your roster has zero analytical support.

The information exists somewhere. The problem is that no single tool connects it to your roster, your league, your scoring settings, and both sides of the ball.

What makes Verdict different

Four things Verdict does.

It knows your roster

Verdict connects to your Sleeper league and reads your team, your leaguemates’ teams, your scoring format, and your pick inventory. Every recommendation is specific to your situation. Not generic advice — your roster, your league, your move.

It covers defense

2,000+ IDP scouting reports. Every linebacker, defensive back, and defensive lineman scored with the same depth as offensive players. IDP trade grades. IDP waiver targets. IDP sit/start. The half of your roster you’ve been guessing on.

It gives you a verdict

Most tools hand you data and leave the decision to you. Verdict gives you the recommendation with the reasoning behind it. A-grade trade? Here’s why. FAAB bid of $23? Here’s the math. Start Luvu over Phillips? Here’s the matchup data. Not charts to interpret. Answers.

It’s built for Sleeper

Native integration. 30-second connection. Reads your format automatically — Superflex, TEP, IDP roster slots, custom scoring. No spreadsheet imports. No generic platform where your league type is an afterthought.

Not a trade calculator

Not a trade calculator

Trade calculators tell you what the market thinks a player is worth. Verdict tells you what makes your team better. There’s a difference.

A calculator says a trade is “fair” based on crowdsourced values. Verdict says the trade fills your WR3 gap, the partner needs a quarterback, and here’s the pitch to send in Sleeper DMs. Fair is a starting point. Verdict tells you whether to actually do it.

Not a rankings site

Not a rankings site

Rankings tell you who’s good. Verdict tells you what to do.

Knowing that a player is ranked 14th at his position doesn’t tell you whether to trade for him, start him this week, or drop him for a waiver target. Verdict connects the dots — your roster’s needs, your league’s landscape, your competitive window — and gives you the action, not just the ranking.

By the numbers

By the numbers

3,000+

Scouting reports generated — including 2,000+ IDP players, scored at the same scale as offense.

4

Proprietary scores per player — Dynasty, Trade Value, Win-Now, and Consistency. Recalculated daily from real NFL production data.

Every roster

Scanned in your league for trade opportunities — across 12 deal structures, graded and ranked automatically.

3

Seasons of historical NFL game data powering the scoring engine. Not one week’s sample. Real multi-year production.

30 sec

To connect your Sleeper league. Paste the ID, pick your team, and everything syncs.

$0

To start. Free tier includes league sync, dynasty scores for every position including IDP, and unlimited Trade Finder searches (3 suggestions per search). No credit card.

Questions about Verdict

Frequently asked.

Is this just another trade calculator?
No. Trade calculators are reactive — you build a trade, paste in the names, and get a grade. Verdict is proactive. It scans your entire league, finds the trades worth making, grades them against your roster’s direction, and writes the pitch. A calculator tells you if a deal is fair. Verdict tells you if the deal makes your team better.
What about free tools?
Free tools show data. Crowdsourced values. Generic rankings. Charts. Verdict shows what to do with it — personalized to your roster, your league, your scoring settings. And if you manage defensive players, you already know the free options leave you guessing — half your roster with no analytical support.
How is the IDP coverage different?
You’ve probably seen IDP treated as an afterthought — a handful of top players, updated occasionally. Verdict has 2,000+ IDP scouting reports — every starting LB, DB, and DL — with dynasty value, trade value, win-now score, and consistency rating. Same depth as offense. Across every feature: trades, waivers, sit/start, scouting, draft.
Do I need to be a Sleeper user?
Yes. Verdict is built exclusively for Sleeper dynasty leagues — that’s where it reads your roster, scoring settings, and leaguemates’ data from. Support for other platforms is not currently planned. If you play dynasty on Sleeper, Verdict was built for you.

Stop guessing. Get your first verdict.

Free to start. Connect your Sleeper league in 30 seconds.

Get your first verdict